Light and Dark on Baker Street

I am dismissive of the virtuous, unaware of the beautiful, and uncomprehending in the face of the happy. So if I didn’t understand I was being asked to be best man, it is because I never expected to be anybody’s best friend…and certainly not the best friend of the bravest and kindest and wisest human being I have ever had the good fortune of knowing.

With that, the viewer realizes that the world’s greatest and most socially awkward consulting detective is not quite the same man he was when we met him in “A Study in Pink,” the first episode of the hit BBC show Sherlock. And if you’re like me, it’s also the moment in which you realize 1) You actually love Sherlock Holmes, vastly intelligent idiot that he is, and 2) You see John Watson as nothing less than the real hero of the story.

“The best and wisest men I have ever known…the Baker Street boys, Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson.”–Mary Morstan Watson

Before I go any further, let me confess that I haven’t seen Season 4 yet! But Christmas is a-coming, soooooo…hint-hint, Mom. Also, this is hardly the first time I’ve watched the other seasons: they’ve been in my personal library for years. But thanks to Emily over at The Altogether Unexpected and a renewed appreciation for Benedict Cumberbatch (I blame Doctor Strange entirely), I figured it was high time I gave Sherlock another whirl.

May I just say, it was an incredibly good decision. This show is brilliant. The writing is so clever, the acting is superb, and most of the mysteries are highly enjoyable capers worthy of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s original stories. I love the London aesthetic, too: that distinct mix of rain, grit, history, modernity, and proud British elegance.

Sometimes Sherlock can get pretty dark. James Moriarty still gives me the creeps, and I’ll never forget the dull, sinking feeling I had when I first saw Sherlock go into full-blown Jack Reacher Mode in “His Last Vow.” But there’s something else–or rather, someone else–I’ve noticed on this re-watch: someone whose goodness and common sense make this a worthwhile show.

That person is John Watson.


Sherlock describes John as “the doctor who never came home from the war.” This reminds me one of the most beautiful lines in Doctor Who (unsurprising, since Steven Moffat wrote them both): “Demons run when a good man goes to war.” John, a veteran of the War on Terror, is definitely a good man. He’s considerate, self-disciplined, kindhearted, and blessed with a healthy dose of prudence and discretion. More importantly, he has a strong moral compass. Right is right and wrong is wrong with John. You can depend on him to stand on principle even if no one else will.

Sherlock is the exact opposite…at least at first. He has no tact whatsoever; he’s manipulative and demanding; he’s manic and obsessive. If he shows any kindness or tenderness to anybody, it’s probably going to be his elderly landlady, Mrs. Hudson– and even she’s on the receiving end of his sharp tongue at some point or another.

No one really dares to stand up to Sherlock until John enters the picture. He just isn’t afraid of this high-functioning sociopath. Sherlock may be outrageously intelligent (and quite aware of it), but John certainly doesn’t mind telling him he’s a jerk. He doesn’t even mind walking out of 221B Baker Street when Sherlock gets too argumentative or cold, thus communicating to the stunned detective that the world doesn’t actually revolve around him. (Shocker!!!)

But John doesn’t just set boundaries: he also looks after his bizarre and brilliant flatmate. He not only helps him with his cases–especially when they involve emotional elements Sherlock simply can’t comprehend–but he tries to make sure Sherlock takes care of himself. (I even read that Benedict Cumberbatch gained weight for Season 2 in order show how living with John improved Sherlock’s physical and mental state.)

John is not impressed by Sherlock’s cheekbones. This is good for Sherlock.

Defending, protecting, and comforting are second nature to John Watson. This is why he’s so gentle with Mrs. Hudson, why he falls in love with the desperate Mary Morstan, and why he consistently directs (or shoves) Sherlock towards what’s right, honorable, and kind. Ultimately, though, it’s why he stays with Sherlock. John knows his prickly friend needs protecting as much as the next person–and that even Sherlock needs someone to believe in him.

His loyalty doesn’t go unnoticed. When we first meet Sherlock, he probably would’ve rather died than open up to a friend. That would be sentiment–and that is “a chemical defect found in the losing side.” But by Season 3, he’s changed his tune quite a bit. He’s actually prone to genuine smiles and laughter. He falls all over himself trying to please (and protect) Mary Morstan, is so much gentler with Molly Hooper, and clumsily but meaningfully expresses his respect and affection for John. He even survives a gunshot wound by sheer willpower just so he can keep John and Mary safe, then risks everything to preserve their future together.

I would argue that this is all a result of the hardheaded but unfailing kindness of John Watson.

“Heroes don’t exist, and if they did, I certainly wouldn’t be one of them,” the detective bitterly informs the doctor in “The Great Game,” the final episode of Season 1. But in “His Last Vow,” the conclusion of Season 3, Sherlock has this very interesting conversation with his brother Mycroft:

Mycroft: “[Charles Augustus Magnussen] is a necessary evil, not a dragon for you to slay.”

Sherlock: “A dragonslayer? Is that what you think of me?”

Mycroft: “No…It’s what you think of yourself.”

Sherlock really doesn’t argue with this…and within minutes, he does slay his dragon. I can’t approve of his methods, but I can certainly acknowledge that he took those risks only because of a friendship that had changed him from the inside out.

“I am dismissive of the virtuous, unaware of the beautiful, and uncomprehending in the face of the happy,” Sherlock confesses at John and Mary’s wedding in “The Sign of Three.” But if his slow but sure character development over the course of the first 9 episodes tells me anything, it’s that even the most difficult people can be changed by the gentle touch of the good, the true, and the beautiful.

8 thoughts on “Light and Dark on Baker Street

  1. I will always have a fierce love of John Watson, and Martin Freeman’s Watson more specifically. He made me love this show even before I came to appreciate Cumberbatch and Moffat and everything else about the show.

    He is definitely a hero!


    1. They are currently my Fave Babes and I am going to be SO UPSET when I finish this re-watch. Maybe I should watch the Bilbo & Smaug scene at the end of The Desolation of Smaug to soothe my poor soul 😉

      (On that note, the fact that Marvel never conjured up a scene where Doctor Strange and Agent Ross could’ve crossed paths is CRIMINAL. It wouldn’t have had to be anything big, but we’d still be tugging our earlobes from the shrieks of every fangirl/fanboy across the world.)


  2. THIS POST. THIS POST. *inserts nonexistent dancing and screaming emoji* this was so good! I love this so much! And awww thanks for mentioning me lol – so glad I inspired you to re-explore Sherlock! I love Sherlock and John’s friendship. John is the main player in Sherlock’s humanization process, because he’s honest, loyal, protective, and open to giving him a chance. I love that about them both. I loved reading this – such a good post! You hit on everything I love about John.

    *tries very hard not to explode* you must watch season 4!!!! And when you do, blog it up! I can’t wait to see how you enjoy it! And I feel partly responsible because my fanfic has spoilers for s.4 in it *facepalm*


    1. Emily, my friend, you get ALL THE CREDIT for this rewatch, haha! Well…you and Doctor Strange. (*winks*) I need to rewatch all the Cumberbatch things now. Such talent, much wow.

      Personally, I think Sherlock is often very surprised that John has stayed with him so long. Like you said, John gives him a chance, and you get the feeling that so few people have ever done that (Molly and Mary are really the only other ones who do). I also like the parallels here between John and Sherlock and Clara and the Twelfth Doctor: Clara and John are both two strong-willed, practical people who have to deal with these very difficult individuals…yet their kindness and loyalty have profound impacts on both Sherlock and the Doctor. The similarities are, undoubtedly, due to Moffat’s touch, but they’re beautiful and thought-provoking nonetheless!

      I MUST WATCH SEASON 4, YESSSSSSSSSSS. And I will definitely blog and tweet and Instagram it, I promise! I won’t be able to contain myself, haha. Don’t worry about the spoilers–I knew most of them anyway 😉 (And I recently watched that scene on YouTube where Baby Rosie bops Sherlock on the nose with her rattle. Bless Rosie. Babysitting is the best thing that could’ve ever happened to that man.)

      Liked by 1 person

      1. So true! I never thought of it in that way – Sherlock and John like 12 and Clara, but I see it now for sure! Moffat is a genius like that.

        And yes, the baby nose bop was one of my favorite moments of season 4. The Rosie and Sherlock dynamic (when it’s possible) is adorable and makes me squeal ☺️☺️


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.