Music Review: Doctor Who Series 5-9

I’m pretty sure I mentioned in a previous post that my mom and I have been watching Doctor Who together–and it has been fantastic. Her no-nonsense commentary and her indignation if ever I fail to warn her about a Scary Moment are worth their weight in gold. We love Eleven and Twelve the best, agree that Donna Noble and Bill Potts are the most relatable of all the companions, and probably laugh way too hard at Missy. In fact, our only major disagreement has been over whether or not Twelve and Clara are splendiferous together. We’ve decided, with queenly graciousness, to agree to disagree on this subject.

Amid all these adventures with Mom, I’ve had the opportunity to listen to and analyze Murray Gold’s lovely, emotionally-driven music. I’m still familiarizing myself with the music from the Christopher Eccleston/David Tennant eras, so if any of my readers have specific recommendations from those series’ soundtracks, please let me know! I’m most familiar with the music from the Smith/Capaldi years, though…so today, I’m sharing with you my favorite tracks from Series 5-9, almost all of which I listen to every day as part of my Writing Playlist.

I’m also including Amazon links to each track, so you can listen to the sample and/or buy it yourself! “A Good Man?” and “Face the Raven” are the only ones that require you to buy the whole album if you want them; HOWEVER, you can buy them individually on iTunes, and you can still listen to the samples on Amazon.

The Mad Man With A Box*

This track’s title is a little misleading. One would assume (as I did) that it’s the Eleventh Doctor’s theme, but it’s actually a more rousing, adventurous version of Amy’s Theme*. One of the things I love about Doctor Who during Steven Moffat’s tenure is its fairytale quality, and I feel like that really comes through in this piece. The first minute and a half is soft and mysterious, with subdued vocals, a lilting melody, and tinkling chimes in the background. But then it builds to a fierce and triumphant crescendo as Amy Pond finally steps into the TARDIS for the first time with her Raggedy Man, and a whole new adventure begins.

With Love, Vincent *

“Vincent and the Doctor” is undoubtedly one of the best episodes of Doctor Who, and this track comes from the final scene where Amy and the Doctor find Vincent van Gogh’s “thank-you note” in the Musée d’Orsay. I love the French vibe; I’m guessing that that’s some type of accordion we hear at the beginning, the same sort of sound you’d hear on, say, the Ratatouille soundtrack. The first half of the piece is light and thoughtful, but swells into a half-orchestral, half-electronic climax as Amy approaches Van Gogh’s famous sunflower painting.

The Enigma Of River Song*

It’s hard to describe how deeply I love this piece, which comes from the climactic scene of “Let’s Kill Hitler”–the one where a young, conflicted River Song finds out who she is and what she is destined to become. It starts out dark and questioning, a sad and imploring violin standing out among a subdued orchestra…until River finally makes her decision to save the Doctor’s life. Preceded by an unexpected burst of drums, strings and brass, the violin lets forth a desperate, determined solo that builds and builds and BUILDS until a solo trumpet (or horn?) joins in–and oh, it makes your heart want to explode right out of your chest. (I’m listening to it as I write this, by the way–can you tell my emotions are going ninety to nothing?)

Clara’s Theme*

Clara Oswald was my first companion and is still my favorite companion, and this was the first piece of music that jumped out at me when I first watched Series 7 back in the autumn of 2017. Her theme has its own fairytale-like quality, but in a totally different way from Amy’s. Whereas Amy’s theme is more hushed and haunting, Clara’s is light, whimsical, and delicate. The theme does take a short detour into darker, more ominous territory, probably hinting at the baffling mystery of the Impossible Girl–but it rallies right back into a soaring, imaginative melody.

The Long Song*

“The Rings of Akhaten” was the episode that made me realize I’d made a very good decision in starting Doctor Who, thanks to its excellent world-building. The repetitive lyrics of “The Long Song” are, in the story, part of a ceremonial and emotional plea for a hero’s assistance–but although they’re grounded in a specific planet’s ancient culture, one might easily assume the words are supposed to apply to a certain heroic Time Lord, as well. About 3/4 through the song the lyrics end and are followed by an intensifying, choral-accompanied climax. I must admit, I love singing along with this one in the car.

Infinite Potential*

This track immediately follows “The Long Song” in “The Rings of Akhaten.” Like “The Enigma of River Song,” there’s a definite melancholy to it–but unlike “Enigma,” it doesn’t include a marked change of mood halfway through the song. This track is used twice in Series 7–the first time on Akhaten, and the second time on Trenzalore, when the Eleventh Doctor regenerates. The Long Song’s refrain, “Wake up,” dominates near the end. I always find it significant when a piece of music is reused for a regeneration scene. It’s like an echo, a clue that that earlier scene must’ve been really important to the Doctor.

A Good Man? (Twelve’s Theme)*

This track starts out very, quiet, very mysterious, and very dark…until a light, questioning melody breaks out about 45 seconds in. From there, the song continues asking the question (“Am I a good man?”), getting louder and more insistent…until you hear the unmistakable whir of a sonic screwdriver. The question is finally answered as the Twelfth Doctor’s epic theme explodes into being. I really love the counter melodies here: the slower, stronger primary melody, played by the brass section, and the much faster secondary melody, executed by a pretty mean string section.

(The Majestic Tale of) An Idiot With a Box*

Anyone who knows the emotional significance of this track knows why I love it. It’s got some major counter melodies going on, but why? Because one melody is the Eleventh Doctor’s theme…and the other melody is the Twelfth Doctor’s theme. This track comes from that moment in “Death in Heaven” when the Twelfth Doctor finally comes to terms with himself and his identity. It’s kind of like the musical version of that earlier, visual moment when Clara is on the phone with Eleven while Twelve stands right next to her: just as they’re fundamentally the same exact man, their themes are able to intertwine without discord.

Face the Raven*

This track may seem like a surprising addition, since I bawled like a baby for the episode “Face the Raven.” Nevertheless, it’s a noteworthy piece, if only because of that one discordant chord in the haunting piano refrain of Clara’s theme. It sticks out like a sore thumb–yet it’s not accidental. It’s actually a great touch: something truly horrible is about to happen, Clara knows it, and it’s traumatic enough to affect her theme. But when the refrain plays again, a little more than halfway through the song, the discordant chord is gone: Clara, by this point in the scene has accepted her fate. I love the solo violin in the last 30 seconds, too. Part of this track is repeated in the episode of “Hell Bent,” when the Doctor and Clara are discussing whether or not they should use the neural block that’ll wipe either his or her memory.

The Shepherd’s Boy*

If you listen to no other track in this post, listen to this one. This is from the climactic end of that feat of directing, storytelling, and acting, “Heaven Sent.” This is the scene where the Doctor punches through the diamond wall for four and a half billion years, all while telling the story of a shepherd’s boy and a bird on a mountain. Oh, this track…the melody, the drums, the fierce, defiant climax…this is truly my favorite piece of Doctor Who music, and it will make you want to fight the sun. Interestingly, it’s used THREE OTHER TIMES outside of “Heaven Sent.” A more tragic version plays when the Twelfth Doctor makes his stand against the Cybermen in “The Doctor Falls,” while the original version plays at the end of “Twice Upon a Time” when he regenerates. But the one that made me squeak with surprise is actually in the 50th Anniversary Special, “The Day of the Doctor.” A softer version of “The Shepherd’s Boy” plays during the scene in the Gallifreyan barn when the War Doctor, the Tenth Doctor, and the Eleventh Doctor realize they can save their home planet after all! #FEELS

Clara’s Diner*

This simple, soothing, acoustic version of Clara’s Theme is just too lovely to pass up. There’s not much to comment on, really, except to provide a bit of heart-melting trivia: Peter Capaldi really did play this song on his guitar for Jenna Coleman to react against during her last day of filming, and she cried.

The Singing Towers*

Congrats to everyone who got to the end of this post, haha. This one is from the final scene of “The Husbands of River Song,” AKA one of the episodes (along with “The Lodger”) that I watch whenever I need a good laugh. The chorals are gentle and light, while the wind instruments, bells, and piano lend to the shifting moods of sadness, resignation, and finally a joyful surprise worthy of a Doctor Who Christmas special.

Which of these tracks is your favorite? Or do you have a recommendation for me? Let me know in the comments!

P.S. I will be engrossed in Camp NaNoWriMo starting TOMORROW, meaning my blog posts for April will be short and sweet. But I’m planning on writing a big post about my Doctor Who re-watch in May, so stay tuned for that!

10 thoughts on “Music Review: Doctor Who Series 5-9

  1. Doctor Who is my favorite show, ever. I LOVE IT SO MUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUCH.

    Ten is my favorite Doctor, as well as my favorite male character ever and also the only one I’d REALLY like to marry if he were a real person. 😉 Meanwhile, Donna Noble is my favorite companion.

    I’ve never actually paid attention to the music, though. I have a hard time noticing background music when I watch something?

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I LOVE IT SO MUCH TOO!!!!! It’s quirky and beautiful and crazy and whimsical, and I love it. Sometimes I just have to roll my eyes at Certain Blatantly Unbiblical Statements and Aspects–but then again, it often steals from the biblical worldview in absolutely fantastic ways, as all good stories do 😉

      I may be a very odd peep, haha, but I’ve always had this thing for movie/TV soundtracks. The really good ones always jump out at me and, more often than not, influence my emotional responses to this or that scene. That’s probably why I love these tracks so much: they all come from scenes (or represent characters!) that/who mean so much to me, therefore I have Lots of Feelings XD


  2. All wonderful choices here, Maribeth!! Moffat’s era of Who brought us some absolutely fantastic music; even though Murray Gold did the soundtrack for the Davies era as well, and even though there are certain good bits in it, the idea of giving certain characters and ideas and events particular themes and repeating and evolving those themes as the story moved forward didn’t seem to really pick up until Moffat took over. And it was an EXCELLENT idea!! Hearing snatches of companion’s themes long after their gone, as a symbol of the Doctor’s memories and their legacy living on in his heart forever, never fails to get me right in the feels.

    Clara’s Theme is one of my favorite DW themes of them all, it’s just so sparkly and fun, recognizable and so easy to hum at any random moment. ☺️

    This one wasn’t on your list, but I also personally love I Am the Doctor. It’s just so triumphant and gets you excited for the Doctor’s next big speech or universe-saving stunt. I’m definitely going to be setting that one as my phone ringer at some point. 😄

    That Singing Towers song, though…. please tell me I wasn’t the only one who noticed that one get repeated as Twelve was talking to Bill and Nardole for the last time on that battlefield?? And who, upon hearing that particular theme start up at that particular moment, had her desire to start sobbing amplified by about 50??? 😭


    1. (*whispers*) See, this is Reason #1,784 why I prefer the Moffat Era XD Seriously, though, you’re absolutely right: the emphasis on character development during Steven Moffat’s tenure is heard even in the music! And speaking of “snatches of companion’s themes long after they’re gone,” you remember that moment in “The Pilot” when Twelve is about to wipe Bill’s memory, but she stops him just in time by begging him to think about how he’d feel if someone did the same thing to him–and Clara’s theme begins playing so-very-softly in the background? MY HEART.

      “I Am the Doctor”–that’s the one from the end of The Eleventh Hour, isn’t it? When Eleven stands up to the Atraxi? AAAAH, what a great scene! You should definitely make that your ringtone. Mine is Clara’s Theme, so I do not judge anyone their Whovian-themed ringtone, not in the slightest 😉

      YOU ARE DEFINITELY NOT THE ONLY ONE WHO HEARD “THE SINGING TOWERS” IN THAT SCENE. I totally forgot to mention it in the post, but thank you for bringing it up!

      Liked by 1 person

  3. I haven’t even re-listened to these pieces yet, but I’m remembering these scenes and the sheer emotion some of the scenes brought out; especially in Vincent and the Doctor (also I saw Van Gogh’s Sunflowers while in London recently and, holy crap, the feels). I don’t consciously think about the contribution of musical scores when I watch most shows, but I definitely appreciate their significance subconsciously, so reading through these songs and their scenes was a bit of an “ah ha” moment for me.
    Also, just curious (not trying to start anything, I promise), what grievance has your mother with Clara and Twelve?


    1. It’s just so amazing to me, how writers and musicians can come together for a movie or a TV show and use BOTH their gifts to produce that “sheer emotion,” as you called it! Some of the greatest/most popular movies of all time have had the most memorable and award-winning scores. I’m thinking of movies like The Lord of the Rings, Braveheart, Star Wars, and Titanic here–and I think it probably has something to do with the way the music lends something to each of those stories.

      As for your question, I will answer it as graciously as I can! (*nods in a dignified, queenly manner in my mother’s direction*) My mom far prefers the chemistry between Matt Smith/Jenna Coleman over Peter Capaldi/Jenna Coleman, and found Twelve and Clara’s relationship awkward. Which is FINE. She respects my unashamed love for Twelve and Clara, and I respect HER enthusiastic love for Eleven and Clara. (And hey, I love Eleven and Clara, too, so we still agree more than we disagree 😉 )

      I’m just VERY glad that my mother ended up loving Twelve. She simply prefers him with Bill Potts. But I’ll be honest, I was really sweatin’ there for a season and a half, haha! I kept wanting to swat him on the back of the head like Clara does in “Listen” and say, “BEHAVE. I want my mother to like you!” XD


  4. Ah, I see. I loved Clara with both of them; my favorite pairing honestly depends on which season I’m watching at that moment. There is something very specific about Clara and Twelve’s relationship, though — and Twelve himself really — that has this intangible strangeness to it that simultaneously baffles you and makes the most perfect sense.

    Also, ‘Heaven Sent’ and ‘Vincent and the Doctor’ are the two episodes I’ve watched the most, and now I want to watch them both again. These musical commentaries are driving me back into the arms of sadness.
    And beauty.


    1. I agree with you completely about Twelve and Clara! They both learn so much from each other, too, in spite of all the frustrating bumps and wobbles of Series 8. For his part, he learns so much from her about tactfulness and compassion; he would’ve never been the kinder, gentler, more joyful Doctor he is in Series 10, with Bill, if it weren’t for Clara’s influence (which can be distinctly felt and seen all the way from “The Pilot” to “Twice Upon a Time”). And as for Clara, I think she’s an excellent example of someone having to learn to love the unlovable, even when it’s so, so hard to do. She could’ve left him at any time, but she didn’t, even when she really wanted to. That’s HUGE, especially in this day and age when loyalty and love (real, sacrificial love) aren’t valued in the slightest. In a way, it’s a bit of a “Beauty and the Beast” dynamic there for Clara–and it all starts with that conversation in “Deep Breath” where Vastra tells her, “The Doctor needs us, you more than anyone. He is lost in the ruin of himself, and we must bring him home.” And Clara manages to do that, in spite of herself.

      I can wax eloquent on the subject of Twelve/Clara, I’m afraid XD

      Heaven Sent is a masterpiece. Every time I watch it, I notice something new–besides being consistently blown away by Peter Capaldi’s talent. And as for Vincent and the Doctor–OH, the sheer whimsy and joy of it! I want to watch it soon with one of my younger sisters; she’s been wanting to see more of Doctor Who, and I feel like that’s the perfect episode if you want to introduce someone to the show 🙂


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.