Movie Review: “Signs”


Before I dive into my first review in months, I just wanted to say THANK YOU for the incredible response to last week’s Operation Lionhearted cover reveal! I got over 200 views on that post alone, not to mention all the buzz on Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter. Many thanks, too, to everyone who shared the cover reveal on their own platforms, the ARC readers who posted reviews on Goodreads, and for all the ebook preorders! Y’all are awesome.

Me all day on Monday, watching the lovely comments rolling in!

I don’t usually post on the blog two weeks in a row–but I’m actually taking a social media hiatus next week in order to clear my mind and soul before the Operation Lionhearted Blog Tour. So consider this review a bit of a “catch up” post. Signs* is a movie I’ve wanted to write about ever since I saw it a few weeks ago, and I’m glad for the chance to finally give it a shout-out.

All pics from Google Images

Having lost his religious faith after the horrific car accident that claimed the life of his wife, the emotionally broken former Episcopal priest, Graham Hess, retreats to a remote farm surrounded by corn in Pennsylvania to live with his two young children and younger brother. Six short months later, a sinister undercurrent of dread starts to take over the family when mysterious crop-circle formations appear in his field, and the same circular patterns manifest all over the world. More and more, as equally unexplained happenings occur, grief and denial mix with paranoia, making a highly volatile combination. Is this an elaborate hoax, an ominous sign from above, or could it be, indeed, the end of the world as we know it?

IMDB synopsis

When we sat down to watch Signs*, I confess to some initial skepticism. For one thing, I’ve always associated M. Night Shyamalan with creepy films–and for another, I somehow misread the back cover and thought Mel Gibson and Joaquin Phoenix were playing shapeshifting aliens masquerading as humans. (Now that would have been wild.)

Best reaction to an alien sighting EVER.

My reservations quickly faded, however, once we started the film and I realized that yes, the Hess brothers are human. Our family is on a Mel Gibson kick thanks to a recent rewatch of Braveheart, and it became delightfully apparent in this opening scene of Signs* that we were about to see him in full-blown Dad Mode. If you’ve been following this blog for a certain amount of time, then you know that Dad Mode is one of my great weaknesses. (See also: The Mandalorian.)

I was also intrigued by the unique premise: “alien invasion meets one man’s faith struggle.” Gibson’s character, Graham, is a hollowed-out shell after the tragic death of his wife; once an Episcopal priest, he no longer even leads his church. But what no one knows except for his brother Merrill is that Graham has actually turned his back on God Himself. How could a good God allow his wife to die so horrifically? Graham insists he no longer believes in God, that God doesn’t even exist–and he angrily expresses this new belief to a stunned Merrill while they watch aliens invade their planet.

Merill and the kids “protecting their brains” from the aliens

I hesitate to say too much more about the plot. Some of it is pretty far-fetched: why, after all, would these particular aliens with this particular weakness (I dare not say what it is!) invade this particular planet?! But Graham’s fierce wrestling with God is still the most compelling thing about this film. As the situation becomes more dire and the family farmhouse comes under attack from the aliens, the viewer and Merrill both realize that Graham isn’t quite the atheist he claims to be. In his most desperate moment, he doesn’t roll over in passive despair. Instead, he begins accusing God and insisting he hates Him.

It’s a moment of horrible, brutal honesty. Graham does believe God exists; perhaps he never stopped believing that. But he doesn’t believe God is good anymore. His agonized cries as he cradles his suffocating little boy bring to mind that famous quote from Saint Teresa of Avila: “If this is how You treat your friends, then no wonder you have so few!”

The breathtaking truth, however, is that even as Graham lashes out, God does not hate him. In fact, He loves Graham. Even in this moment of pain and fear, God sits with Graham, sustaining him and his family, and in His loving Providence He’s has already set their salvation in motion.

“See, what you have to ask yourself is what kind of person are you? Are you the kind that sees signs, that sees miracles? Or do you believe that people just get lucky? Or, look at the question this way: Is it possible that there are no coincidences?”

Signs* is clever and very entertaining, despite the inexplicable plot hole about the aliens choosing this particular planet. Random and often hilarious little incidents throughout the movie carry far more weight than you’d ever expect–and when each incident’s true significance hits you, it’s is enough to make you shriek. The terrible suspense of an alien invasion is also tempered by some truly adorable, family-centered comic relief. And while there are some elements of mild horror, ranging from the harrowing details of a car accident to the Quiet Place-like terror of having bloodthirsty aliens in your house–it’s never gory.

Last but not least, it is a remarkably honest film–perhaps not the most theologically precise, but certainly one that honors the sovereignty and goodness of a tender and patient God.

6 thoughts on “Movie Review: “Signs”

  1. This is one of my favorite movies. I love it so much. Graham discovers God had a plan after all, that his wife’s “meaningless” phrase upon her death wasn’t meaningless after all, and that all things work together for good. The idealism and raw emotional truth that bleed through in this movie are just… powerful. (No, the director doesn’t just do horror films. I also love “The Village,” which is about attempting to keep out evil. You can’t. It’s inborn in the human soul. He explores deep themes quite often.)


    1. Oh, okay!! That’s good to know. The only other movie my sisters tried to watch by this director was “The Woman in Black,” and they were too creeped out by it to finish. On the other hand, I’ve heard that his most recent film, “Old,” is VERY good.


  2. Wait, this film has the talents of both M. Night Shyamalan AND Mel Gibson??! How did I not know this??! I MUST watch it now!!

    I’ve actually been meaning to give this film a try already; I knew it existed (thanks to Amazon knowing far too well the sorts of things I like to watch and the writers/directors/actors I tend to enjoy and playing into those likes with their devious advertising schemes), but it was only very recently that I found out about the faith aspect of the story. That’s what caught my attention.

    I’ve also been watching The X-Files for the first time recently, and the way that entire show is constructed in parallels to faith has me thinking again about how sci-fi seems to have a unique ability to address theological questions and holds themes that relate to faith very well. Which only reminds me that C. S. Lewis was, as we all already know, a very smart man, as he realized this long ago.

    Thanks for sharing this review, Maribeth; it’s definitely encouraged me to watch this film ASAP! 😁


    1. SHAY, IT’S SO GOOD. I really think you would like it!! I’ve never seen The X-Files, but I’ve heard a lot of great things about it. And you’re so right: C.S. Lewis had a bead on science fiction loooooooong ago. Although I must admit, it’s been FAR too long since I’ve read his Space Trilogy. I really need to remedy that soon.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.